A while ago I spent about four longish posts criticizing Alice von Hildebrand. I see that others are now stepping up to the plate.
There is a beaut here wherein Janet E. Smith makes it quite clear, albeit in the nicest way possible, that von Hildebrand doesn't have a clue what she is talking about. It's worth reading if you care about the debate and not if not.
H/T la nouvelle théologie
I wasn't going to comment on this since I've put Alice behind me. But these two articles appeared today in my "Commonweal Online" email and this seemed an appropriate place to post them since they illustrate how nobody is paying any attention to Alice.
ReplyDelete"Further Adrift" by Peter Steinfels
http://commonwealmagazine.org/further-adrift
and
"Long Good Bye" by Cathleen Kaveny
http://commonwealmagazine.org/long-goodbye
Perhaps this should be a separate thread, or not.